Madison Goodtime Apparently, she was almost holding a snowflake, a diamond, and an orange before she ended up landing The Secret Lives of Mormon Women: Orange County.
“When I lived in Los Angeles for years, they asked me to be there The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills and I turned it down,” Madison, 34, claimed on the Wednesday, May 13, episode of “Unplanned.” Podcastsuggesting that she was also reportedly asked to audition The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City. “Then I moved to Orange County and they asked me to be a part of it the real housewives of OC and I said no. And then I moved to Utah and then back to OC and they asked me to be on (the show) again.”
The third time, Madison said she agreed to comply with Bravo’s alleged interview request.
“This was my first time participating in the interview. Wanted to see the vibe, you know?” Madison remembered. “I ask myself, ‘Why do I always say no? Maybe I should just do something.’ I attended the interview and then they wanted me to meet the other woman and they really wanted me to do it. Finally I got really nervous and said, “I don’t know.” I just don’t really feel like it’s right.’ Then I just rejected it.”
months after the decline RHOC Again, Madison was offered a spot on the upcoming Hulu series Mormon women Spin-off takes place in Orange County. (The OG version of the network is based in Utah and follows a group of young Mormon influencer moms.)
“It felt more right because the girls are my true friends. I’m LDS,” Madison explained, noting that she has been close with most of her colleagues for decades. “I felt like it wasn’t that scary because I knew everyone in it and it was our first time doing it together. It’s not like you jump into a cast that’s been there for so long and you’re the new girl.
We’re all starting this at the same time (and) it’s something new for all of us.”
Madison will appear on Mormon Women: OC next to Aspyn Ovard, Avery Woods, Salomé Andrea, McCall DaPron, Ashleigh Pease, Chandler Higginson Brooks And Bobbi Althoff. That is also likely Jen Affleck from the OG reality TV series will make the jump to the new show after moving from Utah to California.

Aspyn Ovard, Avery Woods, Bobbi Althoff, Salomé Andrea, McCall DaPron, Ashleigh Pease, Madison Bontempo and Chandler Higginson Brooks attend Hulu’s Get Real House in April 2026.
Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty ImagesJen, 26, rose to fame as a member of MomTok Taylor Frankie Paul, Whitney Leavitt, Mayci Neeley, Mikayla Matthews, Layla Taylor, Miranda McWhorter And Demi EngemanThe latter left the show before season 5.
Madison has her own connections to the OG crew.
“I knew Demi, her ex-husband (Blake Corbin) was his best man,” Madison said on Wednesday’s episode, referring to her husband Kyler Fisher‘s bridal shower. “We knew it Dakota (Mortensen) and Taylor because Dakota tiled our bathroom in Utah when we were remodeling and then we met Taylor at the gym. Then I went to high school with Mayci.”
It is not known whether any of the Mormon women OGs will make the jump to the OC spinoff, even though McCall, 36, is one of Mayci’s older sisters.


